In the valve industry, gate valves are favored for their simple and reliable design, as well as their wide range of applications. However, despite their excellent performance in many fluid control scenarios, gate valves are not always the ideal choice. This article will explore situations where gate valves are not recommended, helping engineers and technical personnel make better decisions.
Gate valves are designed for fully open or fully closed positions, but they may not be the best choice for systems that require frequent operation. This is because opening and closing a gate valve requires multiple turns, making the process relatively slow. Frequent operation can lead to increased mechanical wear and shorten the valve's lifespan. Therefore, in applications that require quick response or frequent opening and closing, such as emergency shutdown systems, ball valves or butterfly valves, which can be quickly opened or closed, may be more appropriate.
The primary function of a gate valve is for on/off control, and it is not suitable for regulating flow. If a gate valve is partially opened to throttle flow, the high-velocity fluid passing through can erode the gate and seat surfaces, leading to seal failure and possibly causing vibration issues. Additionally, a partially open gate valve can create flow turbulence and pressure drops, reducing system efficiency. For applications that require precise flow control, such as reaction control in chemical processes or flow regulation in water supply systems, control valves or ball valves are more suitable.
While gate valves can be used in high-pressure systems, their performance is not always optimal in extreme high-pressure or high-temperature environments. For instance, in high-temperature steam systems, the sealing surfaces of a gate valve may expand or contract due to temperature fluctuations, leading to leaks or operational difficulties. In contrast, ball valves or globe valves generally offer better sealing and operational performance when handling high-temperature and high-pressure fluids. Additionally, gate valves in some high-pressure systems require higher torque to operate, increasing operational difficulty and maintenance costs.
When handling fluids with solid particles, dirt, or sludge, gate valves are prone to clogging or having particles trapped between the gate and the seat. This can prevent the gate valve from fully closing and may even damage the valve. Solid particles can get lodged on the sealing surfaces of the valve, causing wear and reducing the valve’s lifespan. For fluids containing solid particles, knife gate valves, ball valves, or plug valves are more suitable, as they are designed to handle such conditions more effectively.
Gate valves are typically large in structure, especially in large-diameter applications, where the valve body and actuator take up significant space. If installation space is limited or a compact system design is required, gate valves may not be suitable. In such cases, butterfly valves or ball valves are often better choices due to their compact structure and smaller space requirements. Additionally, the installation and maintenance of gate valves require more room, particularly considering the stem's extension distance.
When a system requires rapid opening or closing, the slow operation of a gate valve can be a disadvantage. The design of a gate valve requires the gate to move vertically along the seat, which means multiple turns of the stem are needed to complete the open or close action. In applications that require emergency shutoff or quick response, the quarter-turn operation of a ball valve is much faster and more efficient.
다음 :
탑 엔트리 볼 밸브란 무엇입니까?
